College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students

Obama's Nobel: Judge deeds by their intentions

By Mohammed S. Helal

Print this article

Published: Friday, October 23, 2009

Updated: Friday, October 23, 2009

“Deeds are to be judged by their intentions”: this is an Arabic proverb that reflects an ancient adage that intentions are just as powerful as deeds, and that notwithstanding the fact that not all good intentions lead to fruition they are still worth recognition. 

The Nobel Peace Prize should not be considered an award to President Obama or for his limited achievements since taking office. Rather, it should be seen as an endorsement of a worldview. A vision of the world that realizes the dream of Martin Luther King Jr. not to judge a human being by the color of his skin, a vision where humanity does not live under the phantom of nuclear weapons, a view of a world where religions and cultures are reconciled and where diversity is celebrated, a global community that recognizes the dangers of environmental degradation and is ready to unite to confront it, and a policy that understands that the challenges of today are global and require global responses.

As an Egyptian, Arab, African, Muslim and Mediterranean citizen of the world, I do not see this is as tribute to the American President, but to humanism, multiculturalism, multilateralism, international cooperation and to humility. 

 

 


Mohamed S. Helal is an LL.M. student from Egypt and a diplomat with the Egyptian Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

Comments

2 comments
menckenlite
Sat Oct 24 2009 20:58
This essay raises contradictions. Saying “Deeds are to be judged by their intentions” conflicts with George Bernard Shaw's dictum that "The road to hell is paved with good intentions," and Cleobulous' observation that "The chief source of evil among men is excessive good." If "A vision of the world that realizes the dream of Martin Luther King Jr. not to judge a human being by the color of his skin," is the goal, why is it important that Obama is the first African American to be President? What does that matter? Saying "I do not see this is as tribute to the American President, but to humanism, multiculturalism, multilateralism, international cooperation and to humility." raises the question why Obama was chosen? There are many humanists who acted for many years to deserve the award. Nominations for this award were closed 11 days after Obama became President. It does not make any sense except to embarrass the Nobel Committee and Obama.
Your name
Sat Oct 24 2009 20:56
This essay raises contradictions. Saying “Deeds are to be judged by their intentions” conflicts with George Bernard Shaw's dictum that "The road to hell is paved with good intentions," and Cleobulous' observation that "The chief source of evil among men is excessive good." If "A vision of the world that realizes the dream of Martin Luther King Jr. not to judge a human being by the color of his skin," is the goal, why is it important that Obama is the first African American to be President? What does that matter? Saying "I do not see this is as tribute to the American President, but to humanism, multiculturalism, multilateralism, international cooperation and to humility." raises the question why Obama was chosen? There are many humanists who acted for many years to deserve the award. Nominations for this award were closed 11 days after Obama became President. It does not make any sense except to embarrass the Nobel Committee and Obama.






log out